Strength Training for Females: What the Evidence Says About Hormones
As a fellow fitness enthusiast, you likely know that strength training provides remarkable health and functional benefits. But gaining noticeable muscle has sometimes felt like an uphill battle for me.
When my own progress stalls, it’s tempting to blame my physiology. Could female hormones like estrogen make building muscle more difficult? Does the menstrual cycle jeopardize results? These questions reflect the shared frustration many women experience with struggling to improve strength and muscle. But is our hormone profile truly destiny, or are other factors more impactful?
Let’s examine how sex hormones may or may not influence training response. While they play a contributing role, their importance is often overstated.
In my own experience, I’ve seen tremendous monthly variations in gains despite consistent training. In some cycles, I excel and break PRs, while others feel like a struggle. But in the long run, these ups and downs balance out.
Have faith in your body’s incredible ability to adapt and grow stronger month to month, year to year. With intelligent programming, patience and consistency, you will progress
What Differences Do Male vs. Female Physiology Actually Make?
On average, men start with more baseline muscle mass and strength, along with stable testosterone levels. The testosterone surge during puberty enables men’s growth spurt and increased muscle accumulation.
This can create the perception that men have an unfair advantage in building muscle thanks to higher testosterone. However, a closer analysis reveals a more nuanced reality. When training volume and regimen are equalized, women gain comparable relative muscle and strength to men.
For example, if a woman adds 5kg to her bench press strength over 12 weeks of consistent training, her relative improvement mirrors that of a man adding 5kg. While she may lift less total weight (since she started from a lower base of strength), her proportional gain is similar.
Additionally, natural testosterone variations within the normal range in men show little correlation with the magnitude of their strength increases from training. In truth, an array of factors beyond hormones influence training responses across genders, including nutrition, sleep, stress, injury history, genetics and programming specifics.
While average differences between the sexes exist, consistency of proper training is what ultimately yields progress over time. Hormones alone should not be singled out as the limiting factor.
Ovarian Hormones - Are Monthly Fluctuations Meaningful?
What about your own hormone fluctuations each month with the menstrual cycle? Some aim to strategically time training cycles to these shifts through an approach called “menstrual phase training.”
For instance, emphasising resistance training in perceived high estrogen phases before ovulation, and yoga during elevated progesterone after ovulation. However, does the evidence support altering your workouts to align with your cycle?
Unfortunately, existing research reveals minimal changes to performance at different menstrual phases for most women. Small studies note minor variations in strength at different times which diminish after accounting for other variables.
This lack of significant change is unsurprising given the enormous normal variations in cycle length, phase duration and ovulation timing between individuals.
Unless you rigorously track ovulation through lab hormone testing for several consecutive months, you cannot reliably identify true high and low hormone phases to leverage. For most, attempting to schedule training by cycle phase becomes guesswork.
Beyond limited evidence, practical problems exist with this approach. Radically changing your training split every 2 weeks defies core principles for progress like consistency, gradual overload and progression.
Avoiding lower body exercises for half your cycle, for example, could hinder strength development. Those with highly irregular cycles cannot effectively follow rigid programming timed to estimated phases.
Overall, current science indicates synchronising training to your menstrual cycle offers a negligible advantage for most women. Seeking sustainable, progressive programming appears to be a more productive focus.
Does Hormonal Birth Control Help or Hurt Training Adaptation?
If trying to leverage natural hormone fluctuations lacks scientific backing, what about deliberately overriding them with birth control pills or devices?
Hormonal contraceptives provide synthetic estrogen and progestin while suppressing normal ovulation patterns and variations. Could this impairment gain?
Reassuringly, the majority of studies find oral contraceptives have minimal impact on muscle building and strength. For most women, being on the pill does not help or hinder training adaptation and results.
A smaller subset may notice changes after starting or stopping birth control. However, any effects are highly individual. As with any medication, be attentive to how your body feels week-to-week and discuss any concerns with your healthcare provider.
For the average woman though, research indicates hormonal birth control poses no major advantages or obstacles to making progress in the gym. It is unrealistic to view it as the key variable that will make or break your fitness goals.
Consistency and Long-Term Progression Trump Short Term Fluctuations
Given the evidence, baseline sex hormone profile and monthly shifts do not appear to substantially dictate training response and gains. Why then do some women seem to increase muscle and strength effortlessly while others struggle?
The reason is that while hormones play a contributing role, your overall results emerge from a complex intersection of lifestyle factors including fitness history, nutrition, sleep, stress management, age, genetics and specific program variables.
Just as there exists a spectrum of low, moderate and high responders to strength training among men, there also exists a wide range of responses among women regardless of menstrual details or birth control use.
Two women could follow the exact same thoughtfully designed training protocol and experience vastly different results in muscle gains and strength improvements based on their unique biology and behaviours. Progress remains highly individualised.
Rather than focusing too narrowly on endocrine factors, strive to cultivate body awareness through consistent tracking of your workouts, nutrition, sleep, stress levels and other signals.
Learn to gauge day-to-day energy, aches, and fatigue and intuitively auto-regulate your training as needed rather than attempting to micromanage assumed monthly hormone phases.
Your body provides real-time cues on when to push harder or pull back that outweigh longer cyclic hormonal changes. Skilful self-assessment enables sustainable progress and helps prevent overtraining or inadequate training.
Trust your body’s innate wisdom over trying to biohack speculated monthly hormone fluctuations. Consistency and gradual progressive overload ultimately drive results over the long run.
Navigating Menopause: What Changes, and What Doesn't?
Entering our 40s and 50s brings declining estrogen and progesterone signalling menopause. Does this necessitate completely revamping your training program?
Some degree of muscle mass loss is inevitable as part of the ageing process. By your 50s and 60s, you may lose 15-30% of muscle compared to your 30s, at a rate of up to 3% loss per year after 50 if you don’t strength train.
Accelerated loss can occur during menopause partially attributable to estrogen decreases, based on correlational data from longitudinal studies. However, the exact causal relationships remain speculative and need further research.
Seeking proactive strategies to counteract age-related losses makes sense. The good news is that properly designed resistance training remains your most potent anti-ageing strategy regardless of hormonal changes.
Through menopause and beyond, smart strength training continues stimulating muscle protein synthesis and preserving strength, mobility and independence. You can still make remarkable gains well into your 40s, 50s and 60s with a thoughtful program.
Focus on mastering good form, building foundational mobility, and developing a sustainable regimen tailored to your needs and recovery capacity. Auto-regulate training volume and intensity based on how you feel day-to-day rather than standardised formulas.
Ageing gracefully requires deepening your mindfulness and listening to your body’s signals even more closely. But take comfort knowing you can continue achieving inspiring fitness by lifting weights and moving intentionally throughout midlife and beyond.
A Balanced Mindset Fuels Sustainable Progress
With the intense focus on hormones, it’s easy to view your physiology as failing you and forcing you to biohack everything. But while hormones contribute, obsessively fixing on them often backfires.
Remember, your exercise capacity stems from your total biology, behaviours and lifestyle. To become your strongest, most vibrant self, first prioritize basics like nutrition, sleep, stress management and intelligent training.
Respect your sophisticated physiology. Avoid extreme efforts to manipulate hormones through training or dieting. Rigid approaches frequently fail.
Trust you can make consistent progress by training smart, fuelling well, recovering properly and keeping perspective through ups and downs.
Consistency Over Time Leads to Results
Research continues to provide more effective training and nutrition strategies for women. But the fundamentals are clear.
While hormones affect physiology, their role in fitness is overblown. Monthly fluctuations don’t undermine gains with proper progressive training.
Have faith in your body’s incredible ability to adapt and grow stronger month to month, year to year. With intelligent programming, patience and consistency, you will progress.
Stay focused on building momentum and self-belief over the long haul. Achieving your fitness goals is absolutely within reach by applying sensible, progressive training practices month after month and trusting the process.
Recommended reading
Recommended reading
Additional Resources
Feeling in control of your health
If you are interested in improving your health and wellness, check out other resources such as Our Blog, Free Resources and/or join our private Body-Mind Transformation Secrets Community on Facebook, and go on an even deeper dive with me to uncover how to succeed in your health and wellness goals.
You may also be interested in our Sleep Secrets Cheat Sheet. It is a great resource with strategies to fix and optimize your sleep which is crucial to succeeding in your health and wellness goals.
Resources
Pictures
